West Sussex Unwrapped II: Month 2 – Votes for Women! West Sussex and the Women’s Freedom League

Today, we mark International Women’s Day by taking a look at one of the lesser-known but no less important political groups which advocated women’s suffrage during the early 20th century. The activities of the National Union of Women’s Suffrage Societies (NUWSS) and the Women’s Social and Political Union (WSPU) and their leaders – Millicent Fawcett and the Pankhursts – to win ‘Votes for Women’ are familiar to many of us; but the actions of the Women’s Freedom League – including its Caravan Campaign, which traversed West Sussex – are perhaps less familiar. This latest chapter of West Sussex Unwrapped will explore the Women’s Freedom League’s efforts to win support across the county, and how these efforts can help us to understand the local attitude towards the national campaign for women’s suffrage.

Votes for Women on Film

Emily Wilding Davison’s funeral procession, 1913

Snippet from the film Funeral Procession of the Woman Who Dared by Screen Archive South East, part of the series for West Sussex Unwrapped.

Images should not be reproduced without permission from West Sussex Record Office.

Votes for Women in the Archives

Four women in a line holding hands, wearing purple, green and white clothing. The women are dressed as a tennis player, leisured lady, housemaid and cook.
Suffrage postcard, ‘Unity is Strength’ c1910 (Acc 19737 008)

The Women’s Freedom League (WFL) was founded in September 1907 after a series of disputes about the constitution and direction of the WSPU caused a breakaway group of women – led by Charlotte Despard, a leading suffragist, and including Anne Cobden-Sanderson, daughter of the Liberal politician Richard Cobden (who had a family home at Heyshott, near Midhurst) and sister of Jane Cobden Unwin, a fellow suffragist and one of the first female London County Councillors – to set up their own movement. Although it was a militant movement, the WFL advocated non-violent methods of protest; yet its members would be arrested frequently and incarcerated for their actions.

Sepia portrait of Muriel Matters, seated with a book, looking directly at the camera
Muriel Matters in a publicity portrait taken for the Women’s Freedom League (London School of Economics, TWL.2002.67)

One of the WFL’s leading members was Muriel Matters. An Australian actress, Muriel moved to England in 1905 and joined the WFL soon after its inception. She would later become famous as one half of a pair of suffragists who chained herself to the so-called Grille (a brass latticework screen which had been erected to shield women visitors from the view of sitting MPs) in the House of Commons in October 1908 – the entire grille had to be removed from its fixings before a blacksmith was able to remove their chains; and in 1909 she took to the skies in an airship emblazoned with the motto ‘Votes for Women’, with the intention of dropping handbills over the King as he progressed from Buckingham Palace to Parliament, for its state opening.

Before these exploits, however, Muriel was ‘Organiser in Chief’ for the WFL’s Caravan Campaign, and from May – October 1908, she traversed the South Downs in an attempt to bring the WFL and its campaign to the towns and villages nestled amongst its landscapes. Setting off from Charlotte Despard’s house in Oxshott, Surrey, on 16th May 1908, Muriel eventually arrived at Midhurst, her first stop in West Sussex, on 30th May. Perhaps because of its connection to the Cobdens, Midhurst was considered ‘one of the brightest and most likely spots for seed to take root’ and an open-air meeting ‘drew many hundreds of residents’. After a weekend in Midhurst the caravan moved to Petworth and hosted another open-air meeting, before heading on to Chichester, where two meetings were held, apparently to limited success, ‘the first drawing many hostile roughs’ and the second meeting falling victim initially to ‘hostility’, due to the women’s ‘doubtful reputation’; when their ‘stolid respectability’ was proven, they instead fell victim to ‘the spirit of apathy’.

Two women are standing on rear step of the caravan with a third, seated woman (unidentified). Women's Suffrage and Women's Freedom League are written on the side of the caravan.
Promotional postcard featuring the WFL’s suffrage caravan, probably in a yard in St Pancras, Chichester, with Muriel Matters on the left and possibly Madge Turner on the right (London School of Economics, TWL.2002.327)

From Chichester, Muriel drove the caravan to Bognor, spending a long weekend in the town where she held a number of meetings, both in the open air and at private houses, before heading to Littlehampton. From Littlehampton, Muriel – who was accompanied throughout her tour by Lilian Hicks, a seasoned suffrage campaigner – visited Yapton, ‘a small village with an enlightened vicar’ but found ‘unintelligent and offensive opposition’ when they held their meeting. After a short break from the campaign, so that the women could return to London to join the NUWSS’s mass march and meeting, held on 13th June, the caravan was back on the road. The next stop was Angmering, where Muriel found that ‘as in other parts, the women seemed to be much more intelligent than the men’, before heading to Findon, where – conversely – they succeeding in converting several men, as well as women. The caravan then moved on to Cowfold, West Grinstead and possibly Horsham before heading to Crawley and East Grinstead towards the end of June, and thence further into East Sussex and Kent.

Muriel’s journey and experiences in West Sussex can be traced using Votes for Women, the WFL’s bulletin, which was included in Women’s Franchise. Unfortunately, while Muriel’s earlier exploits are recorded in Votes for Women, lack of space meant that although she submitted reports of her visits to Crawley and East Grinstead, they were not published, and there is some uncertainty regarding the stops made in that area of the county.

Flag shape with three horizontal stripes, white (top), yellow (middle), dark green (bottom), with 'WFL Dare to be Free' printed in white on the bottom stripe
WFL banner c1908 (London School of Economics, TWL.1998.05)
Excerpt from an article in the Bognor Observer, reporting on the WFL’s experiences in Chichester and Bognor (June 10th 1908)

Muriel’s reports are a delight to read and convey a real sense of her character. Muriel’s dry – sometimes sardonic – humour is evident throughout, along with a stoicism and devotion to both the WFL and the wider campaign. They also hint at the very real physical danger which Muriel and Lilian faced throughout their campaign in West Sussex. As two women travelling the countryside alone, with strongly-held views on a subject which aroused strong responses, in a caravan which afforded little protection, they were vulnerable to the baying mob, although this threat is often brushed aside. Muriel makes passing references to ‘hostile roughs’ with ‘rats and mice in evidence’, intended to scare the speakers (Chichester); ‘eggs and flour’ (Yapton); and having to ‘invite the police sergeant to take a walk around the town with us’ (Bognor). Local, contemporary newspaper reports reveal the true extent of these threats, however.

The Chichester Observer of June 3rd 1908 writes of the first (open air) meeting in Chichester that

A crowd of several hundreds had gathered and it was soon apparent that the majority were not sympathetic, for when Miss Metters [sic] got up to speak, there was a good deal of interruption. She spoke for about a quarter-of-an-hour, but hardly a word of what she said could be heard, and finding that it was useless to go on further, she declared that “under the circumstances” as the men would not allow her to speak she would be pleased to have a special meeting for women. Miss Metters and her supporters then left the steps to proceed to their caravan, which had been placed in Mr Grainger’s yard close by St Pancras Church, but they were immediately hemmed by the crowd, but eventually about half a dozen policemen forced them through. Then a portion of the crowd rushed up East Walls from where they could see the caravan which was then pelted, but the Suffragettes quickly put it under cover.

The Portsmouth Evening News of June 3rd reported that Muriel’s return to the caravan

was the signal for a rush by the crowd and Sergeant Peel and several constables had to go to the protection of the ladies, who were assailed by a shower of old potatoes and mud… For some time, several hundreds of people hung about, expecting the reappearance of the ladies, but by and by they disappeared.

The Bognor Observer of June 10th also documents the Bognor incident in more detail. Muriel’s first open air meeting met with a fair hearing  

but trouble came a little later when she was recognised occupying a seat on the Parade, and at once a spirit of mischief seized the youths, who recognised her. Balls of sand were sent whizzing in her direction, and so uncomfortable did the situation become, and so threatening the rapidly accumulating crowd, that the fair advocate of women’s rights had to seek the protection of police, and the shelter of the police station, whither she was escorted by Sergeant Thomas, followed by a jeering crowd. For some time the demonstrators waited outside the police station expecting the re-appearance of Miss Matters, but the young lady baffled the crowd by resorting to a disguise, the nature of which is only hinted at, and so gained the seclusion of her caravan without further discomfort.

Muriel and Lilian pressed on, however, refusing to be intimidated and believing that their campaign was worthwhile if they converted at least some of their audience, since this would allow seed to take root. After her visit to Findon (16th June), Muriel commented,

It is wonderful to watch the effect that this campaign is having upon these country people, who hitherto have known nothing of the movement, save what they read in the newspaper columns. When we tell them that we really are the same women of whom they read such strange accounts in the London press it makes them pause and reflect. They cannot understand why our speeches have not been fully and faithfully reported in the newspapers. And so our campaign, if doing no other good, is surely causing these country folks to take a kindlier view not only of the movement, but of the women who deal in its ranks.

Meeting to be held on March 28th. Speakers advertised as Reverend Claude Hinscliff and Mrs Cavendish Bentinck, with Mrs de Fonblanque in the Chair
Poster advertising a meeting of the Qui Vive Corps in Horsham, c1913 (MP 1666)

The WFL’s Caravan Campaign did have a positive effect upon West Sussex. In July 1908, shortly after its tour of West Sussex was complete, a West Sussex branch of the WFL was set up – the first, organised suffrage society in the county; and it is perhaps a sign of the campaign’s success that a branch of the Anti-Suffrage League was set up later that same year. The WFL branch’s first meeting was held at Easebourne in August 1908, with the elaborately-named Mrs Florence Gertrude de Fonblanque of Duncton in the chair. Mrs de Fonblanque (the sister of Maud Arncliffe Sennett, a prominent suffragist who served on the WFL’s Executive Committee) would go on to achieve a certain amount of fame as the instigator of the Women’s March of 1912, which saw suffragists walk from Edinburgh to London, and subsequently founded the Qui Vive Corps, based in Horsham, in 1913.

Other members of the West Sussex branch included Ethel Margaret ‘Madge’ Turner of Chichester, who would be arrested and imprisoned in February 1909 for ‘wilfully obstructing the police’ and later worked as an Organiser for the WFL; Elsie Cummins of Easebourne, who served as Branch Secretary and was arrested and imprisoned in July 1909 for obstructing the police in their duty; and Anne Cobden-Sanderson and Jane Cobden-Unwin, with Anne having been arrested and imprisoned in October 1906 for disorderly conduct (somewhat bizarrely, Jane was accused of locking a policeman in a cupboard at her sister’s trial, although she avoided arrest.)

You can find out more about the life of Madge Turner by watching an accompanying presentation on YouTube below, presented by WSRO Archivist Nichola Court.

The meeting included a speech by Mrs Arncliffe Sennett and Elsie Cummins made a short speech
Excerpt from The Vote, summarising a recent meeting of the West Sussex branch of the WFL at Northchapel, chaired by Mrs de Fonblanque (The Vote, 25th November 1909)
Front page
Fourth Annual Report of the East Grinstead Women’s Suffrage Society, for the year 1916 (Add Mss 54753)

Following on from the establishment of the West Sussex branch of the WFL – whose activities can be traced in Votes for Women (in Women’s Franchise) and subsequently in The Vote, the WFL’s standalone magazine – societies affiliated with the NUWSS would be created in Worthing and Cuckfield in 1909, in Littlehampton and Horsham in 1910, and in East Grinstead in 1911. The Bognor Women’s Suffrage Society was formed in 1911, while 1912 saw branches of the WSPU form in Bognor and Worthing. Finally, a branch of the Men’s League for Women’s Suffrage was formed in East Grinstead in 1912, and other non-militant groups were active in Horsham and Haywards Heath (note that Cuckfield, East Grinstead and Haywards Heath were part of East Sussex until 1974).

Although Muriel and Lilian clearly met with hostility, derision and the threat of violence during their campaign, their success cannot be denied. Muriel’s reports suggest that they were often successful in converting only a small number of the audiences; but, as Muriel wrote after leaving Chichester, ‘the spirit of the few is very strong and we feel sure that they will feed the flame’. Given the rapid succession of suffrage groups which were established across the county in its wake, the impact of the WFL’s Caravan Campaign in West Sussex was real and lasting; and those converts not only ‘fed the flame’ but nurtured it and helped it to spread across the county. 

The householder, A M Binnie (female) has written 'No vote, no census. Till women have the rights and privileges of citizenship, I for one decline to fulfil the duties'.
Page from a West Wittering address from the 1911 Census, ‘Filled in by the Registrar on best information available after careful inquiries’. Many suffragists boycotted the 1911 census as part of a national campaign.

Images from The Women’s Library at The London School of Economics and Political Science [LSE] are reproduced by permission. The Women’s Freedom League archive is held at The Women’s Library. Digitised copies of Women’s Franchise and The Vote can be accessed online, via LSE’s Digital Library.
Further information about Muriel Matters and the WFL’s Caravan Campaign can be found in Robert Wainwright’s Miss Muriel Matters: The Fearless Suffragist who Fought for Equality (2017, Allen & Unwin).

Next month, we’ll be looking at the Eastergate School.

Screen Archive South East will showcase a film A New School for Eastergate, which charts the move of Eastergate Church of England Primary School from an unsuitable, overcrowded 19th century building to a new purpose-built open-plan site in 1970.

Look out for Episode 3 on Tuesday the 13th of April!

Stay up to date with WSRO – follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter

One thought on “West Sussex Unwrapped II: Month 2 – Votes for Women! West Sussex and the Women’s Freedom League

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s